CASES · LAW THROUGH CASES

Guangzhou Criminal Defense Lawyers: Full-Process Defense from Investigation-Stage Meetings Through First Instance, Appeal and Petition

We advise on matters governed by the laws of the People's Republic of China. Once a criminal case is set in motion, the time left for a family to react is often very short: after a relative is taken away, every step — the investigation-stage meeting, the application for bail pending trial, and the submission of opinions before arrest is approved — has a definite time window. The most common difficulties suspects and families face: they do not know where the person is being held or what stage the case has reached; they hesitate over whether to retain a lawyer after receiving the detention notice and miss the window for bail; confronted with a confession-and-acceptance statement, they do not understand what signing it means; and some, doubting that a lawyer can help, watch the case drift all the way to prosecution. The criminal process moves stage by stage: during investigation, the fight is for bail and against arrest approval; at the prosecution review stage, for non-prosecution or recognition of a lesser charge; and at trial, for a suspended sentence and mitigated punishment. The thirty-seven days before arrest is approved often determine the course of the months that follow. Criminal cases in Guangzhou all follow the same procedure: investigation-stage meetings take place at Guangzhou No. 1 Detention Center and the district detention centers; prosecution review goes to the district people’s procuratorates; first instance is heard in the basic people’s courts; and second instance goes to the Guangzhou Intermediate People’s Court.

How We Handle a Criminal Defense

  1. The period between detention and the approval of arrest is the critical window for applying for bail pending trial and submitting opinions against arrest. Once arrest is approved, bail becomes markedly harder; counsel should meet the suspect as early as possible, learn the facts of the case, and submit written opinions to both the investigating authority and the procuratorate.
  2. Confession, acceptance of punishment, and return of ill-gotten gains are the core circumstances for lenient handling. A suspect who truthfully confesses may be given a lighter punishment (Criminal Law of the PRC, Article 67(3)); unlawful gains must be recovered or ordered returned (Article 64 of the same Law). Returning ill-gotten gains early, making compensation and obtaining the victim’s forgiveness are important conditions for non-prosecution and suspended sentences.
  3. A not-guilty defense must be built on the elements of the offense. In traffic accident cases, arguing layer by layer from the act of causing the accident, to subjective fault, to causation in the criminal-law sense can shake the foundation of the charge (Criminal Law of the PRC, Article 133). For new types of online conduct, the defense should examine whether an administrative violation has been elevated into a crime, guarding against over-criminalization (Article 285(3) of the same Law).
  4. Defense on characterization — this charge versus that one — directly affects the sentencing range. Impersonating a people’s police officer to swindle involves the concurrence of fraud and the crime of posing as a state organ functionary to deceive (Articles 266 and 279 of the same Law); whether introducing others to gambling constitutes the gambling crime or the crime of opening a casino, and whether intercepting proceeds in a concealment offense separately constitutes theft (Articles 312(1) and 264 of the same Law) — different characterizations can mean a difference of years in prison.
  5. Juvenile cases carry special procedural safeguards. When a juvenile suspect is interrogated, the legal representative must be notified to be present (Criminal Procedure Law of the PRC, Article 281; Law of the PRC on the Protection of Minors, Article 110); a confession made without the legal representative or a suitable adult present may not serve as a basis for conviction. A juvenile accomplice whose circumstances are minor may also qualify for conditional non-prosecution.
  6. In intentional-injury cases arising from civil disputes, self-defense and mitigation arguments should be prepared in parallel. In minor-injury cases arising from mutual affray, establishing a defensive character is realistically difficult; the defense should simultaneously build around the origin of the case, the victim’s fault, compensation and forgiveness, confession and remorse, seeking lenient outcomes such as public surveillance or a suspended sentence (Criminal Law of the PRC, Article 234).

After the First-Instance Judgment

Appeal: The Ten-Day Window

The time limit for appealing a judgment is ten days, and five days for a ruling, counted from the day after the judgment or ruling is received (Criminal Procedure Law of the PRC, Article 227). The limit is not extended; once it passes, the judgment takes effect.

Where the defendant’s side alone appeals, the second instance may not increase the punishment (Article 237 of the same Law). What the second instance can change: where the law was wrongly applied or the punishment was improper, it amends directly; where the facts are unclear or the evidence insufficient, it amends after ascertaining the facts or remands for retrial (Article 236 of the same Law).

The second instance does not necessarily hold a hearing. Appeals in death penalty cases and cases where objections to the first-instance facts and evidence may affect conviction or sentencing must be heard in court; the rest may be handled without a hearing, with only the defendant questioned and the defender’s opinions heard (Article 234 of the same Law). In cases without a hearing, written submissions carry more weight than courtroom statements.

Where the defendant confessed and accepted punishment at first instance, the room on appeal is usually limited; an appeal is worth fighting where the characterization is genuinely disputable, the sentence markedly departs from comparable cases, or the evidence has hard flaws.

Death Penalty Review: The Supreme People's Court Stage

Immediate execution must be approved by the Supreme People’s Court (Article 246 of the same Law), and a death sentence with reprieve by the Higher People’s Court (Article 248). Review is conducted without a hearing; counsel submits written opinions and seeks to present views in person.

The review asks not whether there is guilt, but whether death is warranted: whether the facts are clear, the evidence reliable and sufficient, the characterization accurate, whether mitigating circumstances exist, and whether immediate execution is necessary. The victim’s forgiveness, compensation paid in full, a lesser role in a joint crime, voluntary surrender and meritorious service — all of these must still be raised.

Petition and Retrial: After the Judgment Takes Effect

A party, legal representative or close relative may petition against an effective judgment or ruling, but the petition does not stay execution (Article 252 of the same Law).

A petition needs solid footing: new evidence proving the original findings wrong; evidence that was unreliable or insufficient for conviction; a genuine error in the application of law; a violation of legal procedure that may have affected the fairness of the trial; or embezzlement, bribery or perversion of the law by adjudicators. A petition that offers nothing new and merely voices dissatisfaction with the outcome will essentially not be filed for review.

Sentence Reduction and Parole: What Can Be Won During Service

Commutation turns on repentance and meritorious performance. After commutation, the term actually served may not be less than one-half of the original sentence for fixed-term imprisonment, and not less than thirteen years for life imprisonment (Criminal Law of the PRC, Article 78).

Parole requires that at least one-half of a fixed-term sentence, or thirteen years of a life sentence, has actually been served, with genuine repentance and no risk of reoffending (Article 81 of the same Law). Recidivists, and those sentenced to more than ten years or life for intentional homicide, rape, robbery, kidnapping, arson, explosion, dissemination of hazardous substances or organized violent crime, may not be paroled.

Applications are made by the executing institution and ruled on by the court. What the family can do is cooperate in returning ill-gotten gains, satisfy the property-based penalties, and stay in communication with the custodial facility — all of which factor into the assessment of repentance.

Cases We Have Handled

Non-Prosecution Despite a Primary-Liability Charge in a Traffic Fatality: Attacking Causation

Driving a heavy tractor-trailer, Mr. Li was rear-ended by a truck, and the accident killed an occupant of the other vehicle; traffic police determined that he had fled the scene and bore primary responsibility. After studying the case file, defense counsel argued that Li had been driving normally before the accident, with neither an act of causing an accident nor subjective fault, and that his leaving the scene had no causation in the criminal-law sense with either the accident or the death — the finding of hit-and-run was unclear in fact and insufficient in evidence. The procuratorate accepted the defense, found the facts of the charge unclear and the evidence insufficient, and decided not to prosecute Li.

Read Full Case

Non-Prosecution Defense in Two Juvenile Cases

Xiao Zhang, on an impulse while at a hair salon, committed theft involving RMB 19,000. After counsel stepped in, the family was guided to return the proceeds and compensate, obtaining the victim’s forgiveness, and bail was secured at the first opportunity. When the case moved to prosecution review, after four months of communication and a hearing, the procuratorate decided not to prosecute. Xiao Gao, a student, took part in an affray over a relationship dispute; counsel argued that his involvement was limited, that he was an accomplice and a minor, and the procuratorate applied conditional non-prosecution with accompanying mentorship. Both teenagers ultimately received non-prosecution decisions.

Read Full Case

From Illegal Business Operation to a Suspended Sentence: Defending a Technology-Driven Charge

Mr. Li was investigated for illegal business operation because the team he worked for sold cross-border network access services. After the first court session, the procuratorate on its own initiative changed the charge to providing programs and tools for intruding into computer information systems. Defense counsel maintained a not-guilty defense: Li did only customer-service work, held neither the technical source code nor the servers, and had neither awareness of illegality nor any motive to aid a crime. The court ultimately found the charge established but adopted the mitigating circumstances — accomplice, confession, first offense and remorse — sentencing Li to one year and two months’ imprisonment, suspended for one year and six months, sparing him from custody.

Read Full Case

Introducing a Minor into Prostitution: The Mitigation Path When the Evidence Is Complete

Mr. Wang introduced a fifteen-year-old into prostitution and split the proceeds equally; the chat records, transfers and booking records were complete, leaving the facts undisputed and no room for a not-guilty defense. Attorney Bo Li adopted an integrated strategy of confession and acceptance of punishment, full return of the unlawful gains, and leniency for a first offense: he guided the client to voluntarily sign the confession-and-acceptance statement, directed the family to return the full RMB 3,300 of unlawful gains at the trial stage, and his courtroom arguments were adopted in full. The court convicted Wang of introducing prostitution and sentenced him to six months’ imprisonment.

Read Full Case

Common Questions

My relative has been criminally detained. Can the family visit?

During the investigation stage, family members cannot visit; only defense counsel may meet the detainee. A lawyer’s meeting allows counsel to learn the suspected charge and the facts, verify the detainee’s condition in custody, convey family matters, and promptly apply for bail pending trial and submit opinions against arrest approval to the procuratorate based on what is learned. Upon receiving the detention notice, the family should engage counsel as soon as possible rather than watch the pre-arrest window slip away.

When is the best time to apply for bail pending trial?

The period between detention and the approval of arrest is the critical window. Before arrest is approved, counsel can apply for bail with the investigating authority and submit opinions against arrest to the procuratorate; once arrest is approved, bail becomes markedly harder. Where the circumstances are minor, the suspect has a fixed residence and employment, a suspended sentence is likely, or the suspect suffers serious illness or is pregnant, the prospects for bail are relatively better.

Should the confession-and-acceptance statement be signed or not?

It depends on the state of the evidence. Where the facts are clear and the evidence reliable and sufficient, signing the statement, confessing and accepting punishment, and cooperating in returning the proceeds is the pragmatic path to leniency. Where the evidence is disputable or the characterization problematic, the defense should hold to a not-guilty or characterization defense and not trade substantive argument for leniency. Before signing, have defense counsel review the case file and give an assessment.

Once the case reaches the procuratorate, is non-prosecution still possible?

Yes. Where the alleged facts are unclear and the evidence insufficient, statutory non-prosecution can be sought; where the circumstances are minor and there are mitigating circumstances such as confession, acceptance of punishment and compensation with forgiveness, discretionary non-prosecution can be sought; and for a juvenile accomplice whose circumstances are relatively minor, conditional non-prosecution is also available. Submitting a legal opinion and communicating fully with the prosecutor during the review stage is a key part of counsel’s work at that stage.

A traffic accident was ruled hit-and-run. Is non-prosecution still possible?

There is a real chance. A hit-and-run finding does not rest on the single act of leaving the scene; causation in the criminal-law sense between the conduct and the result must also be examined: whether the vehicle was being driven when the accident occurred, and whether leaving the scene was causally connected to the accident and the death — each must be reviewed item by item. In one case, Mr. Li, driving a heavy tractor-trailer, was rear-ended by a truck, causing a death in the other vehicle, and traffic police ruled he had fled and bore primary responsibility. Defense counsel argued that Li had been driving normally before the accident, with neither an act of causing the accident nor subjective fault, and that leaving the scene had no causation in the criminal-law sense with the accident or the death. The procuratorate ultimately found the facts unclear and the evidence insufficient and decided not to prosecute.

A parent was not present when the minor was interrogated. Can the confession be used for conviction?

Under Article 281 of the Criminal Procedure Law of the PRC, when a juvenile suspect is interrogated, the legal representative must be notified to be present; where notification is impossible, the legal representative cannot attend, or the representative is a co-offender, another adult relative, a representative of the school or a minor-protection organization must be notified to attend. An interrogation confession made without the legal representative or a suitable adult present may not serve as a basis for conviction. If the family discovers this situation, they should promptly inform defense counsel so it can be examined and an application to exclude the evidence made.

Caught drink-driving — under what circumstances can a suspended sentence be sought?

Where the blood alcohol level is relatively low, there are no aggravating circumstances such as an accident, and the conditions of confession, acceptance of punishment and first-time, incidental offending are present, there is room for a suspended sentence. In Mr. Xian’s dangerous driving case, his blood alcohol level at the time of the stop was 83.4 mg per 100 ml; defense counsel argued for a suspended sentence on the grounds of minor circumstances, confession, acceptance of punishment and first offense, and the court sentenced him to one month and ten days’ detention, suspended for two months, with a fine of RMB 1,000.

The first-instance judgment is unfavorable. How long is the appeal window, and can an appeal make the sentence heavier?

The time limit for appealing a judgment is ten days, and five days for a ruling, counted from the day after the judgment or ruling is received, and it is not extended. Where the defendant’s side alone appeals, the second instance may not increase the punishment; this restriction does not apply where the procuratorate protests or the private prosecutor appeals.

The judgment took effect years ago. Can I still petition?

Yes — the law sets no deadline for petitions, though a petition does not stay execution. Whether retrial opens turns on whether there is new evidence, whether the evidence for conviction was reliable and sufficient, whether the law was genuinely misapplied, and whether procedure was violated. A petition that merely expresses dissatisfaction without offering anything new will usually not be filed for review.

Where Criminal Defense Usually Stalls

  1. Finding a lawyer too late. The problem: after a relative is taken away, the family spends time asking around and hesitating, and by the time they decide to engage counsel, the arrest-approval deadline is near, leaving no time to organize the bail application and opinions against arrest. The approach: the procedural windows in criminal cases are measured in days. Upon receiving the detention notice, engage counsel promptly to conduct a meeting and complete the pre-arrest work early.
  2. Wavering over confession and acceptance of punishment. The problem: the family wants lenient handling yet is unwilling to admit guilt, misses the window for signing the statement, and is then dissatisfied with the outcome. The approach: have counsel assess the evidence after reviewing the file — where the evidence is reliable and sufficient, take the confession-and-acceptance path and add return of proceeds and forgiveness; where the evidence or characterization has hard flaws, hold firmly to a not-guilty or characterization defense. Once a direction is chosen, stop wavering.
  3. Treating return of proceeds as buying one’s way out. The problem: the family does not understand the timing and manner of returning proceeds — some pay large sums blindly during investigation, others still refuse to return anything after judgment — and the leniency circumstance is lost. The approach: unlawful gains must be recovered or ordered returned according to law (Criminal Law of the PRC, Article 64), and where a fine is also imposed and the property is insufficient to cover both, civil compensation to the victim comes first (Article 36 of the same Law). The return of proceeds must be coordinated with the overall defense strategy — the amount, the timing and whether it is exchanged for a letter of forgiveness should all be arranged by counsel.
  4. Fixating on acquittal while ignoring the charge. The problem: the family assumes defense means fighting for acquittal, and is insensitive to the distinctions between opening a casino and gambling, between fraud and posing as a state functionary to deceive, and between illegal business operation and other offenses. The approach: a characterization defense is often more readily accepted by the authorities than a not-guilty defense, and reducing a serious charge to a lesser one can substantially cut the sentence.
  5. Overlooking juvenile procedural rights. The problem: the child was interrogated without the parents being notified, yet the transcript is already signed, and the family does not know the consequences of the procedural violation. The approach: a juvenile must be interrogated with the legal representative or a suitable adult present; a confession made otherwise may not serve as a basis for conviction. Upon discovery, report it to counsel promptly and apply for exclusion according to law.

What to Bring Before Engaging a Defender

  1. Identity and relationship materials: the family member’s own ID card, household register, marriage certificate and the like (for the engagement formalities); a copy of the client’s ID card if available.
  2. Procedural documents: every legal document received — the detention notice, arrest notice, prosecution recommendation, indictment, summons and judgment.
  3. Case materials: a written account of the events as the client experienced them, plus chats, transfer records, contracts, receipts and IOUs related to the case.
  4. Compensation and forgiveness materials: proof of compensation, receipts, letters of forgiveness and settlement agreements (if the proceeds have been returned or negotiations are under way).
  5. Special-circumstance materials: medical records and diagnosis certificates (for illness or pregnancy), proof of enrollment or a student card, the minor’s birth medical certificate, and a letter from the employer attesting to usual conduct.

Our Criminal Defense Lawyers

Cases & Articles in This Practice Area