My relative has been criminally detained. Can the family visit?
During the investigation stage, family members cannot visit; only defense counsel may meet the detainee. A lawyer’s meeting allows counsel to learn the suspected charge and the facts, verify the detainee’s condition in custody, convey family matters, and promptly apply for bail pending trial and submit opinions against arrest approval to the procuratorate based on what is learned. Upon receiving the detention notice, the family should engage counsel as soon as possible rather than watch the pre-arrest window slip away.
When is the best time to apply for bail pending trial?
The period between detention and the approval of arrest is the critical window. Before arrest is approved, counsel can apply for bail with the investigating authority and submit opinions against arrest to the procuratorate; once arrest is approved, bail becomes markedly harder. Where the circumstances are minor, the suspect has a fixed residence and employment, a suspended sentence is likely, or the suspect suffers serious illness or is pregnant, the prospects for bail are relatively better.
Should the confession-and-acceptance statement be signed or not?
It depends on the state of the evidence. Where the facts are clear and the evidence reliable and sufficient, signing the statement, confessing and accepting punishment, and cooperating in returning the proceeds is the pragmatic path to leniency. Where the evidence is disputable or the characterization problematic, the defense should hold to a not-guilty or characterization defense and not trade substantive argument for leniency. Before signing, have defense counsel review the case file and give an assessment.
Once the case reaches the procuratorate, is non-prosecution still possible?
Yes. Where the alleged facts are unclear and the evidence insufficient, statutory non-prosecution can be sought; where the circumstances are minor and there are mitigating circumstances such as confession, acceptance of punishment and compensation with forgiveness, discretionary non-prosecution can be sought; and for a juvenile accomplice whose circumstances are relatively minor, conditional non-prosecution is also available. Submitting a legal opinion and communicating fully with the prosecutor during the review stage is a key part of counsel’s work at that stage.
A traffic accident was ruled hit-and-run. Is non-prosecution still possible?
There is a real chance. A hit-and-run finding does not rest on the single act of leaving the scene; causation in the criminal-law sense between the conduct and the result must also be examined: whether the vehicle was being driven when the accident occurred, and whether leaving the scene was causally connected to the accident and the death — each must be reviewed item by item. In one case, Mr. Li, driving a heavy tractor-trailer, was rear-ended by a truck, causing a death in the other vehicle, and traffic police ruled he had fled and bore primary responsibility. Defense counsel argued that Li had been driving normally before the accident, with neither an act of causing the accident nor subjective fault, and that leaving the scene had no causation in the criminal-law sense with the accident or the death. The procuratorate ultimately found the facts unclear and the evidence insufficient and decided not to prosecute.
A parent was not present when the minor was interrogated. Can the confession be used for conviction?
Under Article 281 of the Criminal Procedure Law of the PRC, when a juvenile suspect is interrogated, the legal representative must be notified to be present; where notification is impossible, the legal representative cannot attend, or the representative is a co-offender, another adult relative, a representative of the school or a minor-protection organization must be notified to attend. An interrogation confession made without the legal representative or a suitable adult present may not serve as a basis for conviction. If the family discovers this situation, they should promptly inform defense counsel so it can be examined and an application to exclude the evidence made.
Caught drink-driving — under what circumstances can a suspended sentence be sought?
Where the blood alcohol level is relatively low, there are no aggravating circumstances such as an accident, and the conditions of confession, acceptance of punishment and first-time, incidental offending are present, there is room for a suspended sentence. In Mr. Xian’s dangerous driving case, his blood alcohol level at the time of the stop was 83.4 mg per 100 ml; defense counsel argued for a suspended sentence on the grounds of minor circumstances, confession, acceptance of punishment and first offense, and the court sentenced him to one month and ten days’ detention, suspended for two months, with a fine of RMB 1,000.
The first-instance judgment is unfavorable. How long is the appeal window, and can an appeal make the sentence heavier?
The time limit for appealing a judgment is ten days, and five days for a ruling, counted from the day after the judgment or ruling is received, and it is not extended. Where the defendant’s side alone appeals, the second instance may not increase the punishment; this restriction does not apply where the procuratorate protests or the private prosecutor appeals.
The judgment took effect years ago. Can I still petition?
Yes — the law sets no deadline for petitions, though a petition does not stay execution. Whether retrial opens turns on whether there is new evidence, whether the evidence for conviction was reliable and sufficient, whether the law was genuinely misapplied, and whether procedure was violated. A petition that merely expresses dissatisfaction without offering anything new will usually not be filed for review.