CASES · LAW THROUGH CASES

Guangzhou Personal Injury Lawyers: Handling Traffic Accidents, Personal Injury and Insurance Claims

We advise on matters governed by the laws of the People's Republic of China. A traffic accident or an unexpected injury disrupts an entire family's arrangements: medical bills keep coming while the party at fault pays one installment and goes silent; the insurer pulls out policy clauses to deny the claim; the disability appraisal is done, yet the compensation items and standards remain impossible to figure out. The most common predicaments: the accident determination is in hand, but the injured does not know whom to claim against or which items can be claimed; treatment is still ongoing and no one knows when the disability appraisal should be done; the victim has a pre-existing condition and the insurer uses it to press the price down; or a photo has been stolen by a merchant and the victim wants to act but does not know how to fix the evidence. Have the disability appraisal done after treatment concludes; fix the scene evidence and witness information as early as possible; and list the compensation schedule item by item under the statutory heads — every item left out is an item lost.

How to Claim Personal Injury Compensation

  1. A victim's pre-existing condition or special constitution is not a statutory ground for reducing the tortfeasor's liability: the tortfeasor's liability may be reduced only where the victim was at fault in the occurrence of the harm (Article 1173 of the Civil Code of the PRC). Personal constitution is not fault, and where an insurer presses the price down proportionally on the ground of injury contribution, the court will not adopt it.
  2. Dependents' living expenses shall be counted into the total compensation: where the victim has lost part of the ability to work due to disability, dependents' living expenses are calculated according to the degree of the supporter's loss of working ability, in combination with the dependents' ages and the number of supporters (Article 17 of the SPC Interpretation on Several Issues concerning the Application of Law in the Trial of Personal Injury Compensation Cases) — minor children are calculated to the age of eighteen, and close relatives with neither working ability nor a source of income are calculated for twenty years.
  3. Disability compensation is calculated for twenty years from the date the disability is assessed, reduced by one year for each additional year of age above sixty: the assessment date directly affects the compensation base, so an appraisal should be commissioned promptly once the condition stabilizes; objections to the appraisal opinion must be raised within the evidence submission period by applying for a new appraisal — missing the timing usually forfeits the remedy.
  4. An exemption clause in an insurance contract that the insurer did not flag or expressly explain when the contract was concluded does not take effect (Article 17 of the Insurance Law of the PRC): where the insurer denies a claim on an exemption ground, first examine whether it performed the duty to flag and explain — an exemption clause without such performance cannot block the payout.
  5. A driver who is hit by his own vehicle after getting out becomes a third party: where a motor vehicle accident causes personal injury, death or property loss, the insurer compensates within the liability limit of the compulsory third-party liability insurance for motor vehicles (Article 76 of the Road Traffic Safety Law of the PRC); whether one counts as a third party turns on whether the person was outside or inside the vehicle at the time of the accident.
  6. The cost of enforcing rights against online infringement can be claimed: the reasonable expenses incurred by the infringed to stop the infringement, including notarization fees and attorneys' fees, can be counted into property loss (Article 12 of the SPC Provisions on Several Issues concerning the Application of Law in the Trial of Civil Disputes Involving Infringement of Personal Rights through Information Networks). Where a photo is stolen or a rumor is spread, notarize the evidence first, then talk about compensation.

Personal Injury Cases We Have Handled

A 62-Year-Old Worker Hit by a Car: Compensation Won on Both the Work Injury and Traffic Accident Tracks

Chen, still working on a construction site at sixty-two, was injured in a traffic accident on the way to work; the party at fault and the insurer refused to pay for lost wages on the ground that he was above the statutory retirement age, and the employer denied it was a work injury. The case pursued actual-work evidence for the lost wages while applying for work injury recognition (the procedure by which the labor administration confirms an injury as work-related), and in the end both traffic accident compensation and work injury insurance benefits were upheld. Being above retirement age does not mean the loss of working ability — lost wages from actual work should be compensated.

Read Full Case

Not Listed as a Victim in the Criminal Case — the Civil Claim Won Support After Remand

The client was not listed as a victim in another person's criminal case and filed a separate civil compensation lawsuit, which was dismissed at first instance. On appeal, the second instance revolved around the standard of proof in civil cases: the scope of findings in a criminal case differs from that in a civil one, and a civil tort fact can be found upon a high degree of probability; the case was remanded for retrial, and the client eventually obtained compensation. A loss unresolved in the criminal procedure does not automatically close the door to a civil claim.

Read Full Case

Injury Contribution of Only Ten Percent — the Insurer's Proportional Lowballing Was Not Upheld

The traffic accident victim had a pre-existing condition, and the appraisal opinion found that the external injury contributed only ten percent to the harmful outcome; the insurer accordingly offered to pay only ten percent. The court held that the victim's personal constitution is not fault in law and cannot be a statutory ground for reducing the tortfeasor's liability, and ordered full compensation. Constitution is not fault, and contribution is not a proportion of liability.

Read Full Case

A Huolala Driver's Accident — the Insurer's Rejection on an Exemption Clause Was Overruled

After a driver operating a freight vehicle had a traffic accident, the insurer refused the claim on the ground that the vehicle's use had changed and fell within an exemption. Reviewing the application process revealed that the insurer had not performed the duty to flag and expressly explain the exemption clause, which therefore did not take effect under Article 17 of the Insurance Law of the PRC, and the court ordered the insurer to pay within the coverage. An exemption clause is not a golden shield against payouts.

Read Full Case

Common Questions on Accident Compensation

I am still hospitalized after the crash. When should I start the compensation work?

You can start now: keep the accident determination, the medical records and all medical invoices; record the lost work and nursing situation; and have the disability appraisal done promptly once treatment concludes and the condition stabilizes. The compensation items are directly tied to the assessment date — the longer the delay, the greater the risk of lost evidence and changing standards.

What items can be claimed in a traffic accident?

Reasonable expenses for treatment and rehabilitation such as medical expenses, nursing fees, transportation costs, nutrition expenses and hospitalization meal subsidies, plus income lost from missed work; where disability results, also assistive device costs and disability compensation; where death results, funeral expenses and death compensation (Article 1179 of the Civil Code of the PRC). Dependents' living expenses are counted into the disability or death compensation. Where serious mental harm is caused, moral damages can also be claimed (Article 1183 of the same law).

I have a pre-existing condition and the insurer says it will only pay in part. Is that reasonable?

No. Under Article 1173 of the Civil Code of the PRC, the tortfeasor's liability can be reduced only where the victim was at fault in the occurrence of the harm, and personal constitution is not fault. The injury contribution in an appraisal opinion is a medical judgment of causation, not a proportion of legal liability, and proportional lowballing on that basis is not adopted by the courts.

When should the disability appraisal be done? Can I appoint an agency myself?

Generally after treatment concludes and the condition is relatively stable — too early, and it may be overturned when the condition changes. You may commission a qualified appraisal agency yourself, but if the other side objects in litigation, the court may commission a new appraisal. The timing and the choice of agency greatly affect the compensation outcome — confirm the plan with a lawyer before filing.

The party at fault paid one installment and then stopped. What next?

First calculate the full loss before discussing the rest: items such as medical expenses, lost wages, nursing fees and disability compensation must be calculated item by item under the standards, and the amounts advanced are credited against the final compensation. Where negotiation fails, sue the party at fault together with the insurer — the compulsory insurance and commercial insurance pay first within their liability limits, and the shortfall is borne by the tortfeasor.

I am above retirement age but still working. Can I claim lost wages for an accident?

Yes. Being above the statutory retirement age does not mean the loss of working ability, and lost wages should be upheld where there is evidence of actual work and a source of income before the accident. Work contracts, salary statements, co-worker testimony and attendance records all prove actual work — keep them in ordinary times.

A merchant used my photo in its advertising. How much can I claim?

The amount is determined by the actual loss of the infringed or the gain of the infringer, and where these are hard to determine, the court decides at its discretion according to the circumstances of the infringement (Article 1182 of the Civil Code of the PRC); reasonable expenses such as notarization and attorneys' fees incurred to stop the infringement can be claimed together. Notarize the evidence before filing — fix the infringing pages and the scope of dissemination.

What do I need to prepare to sue someone who spread rumors and insulted me online?

Three categories of evidence: notarized preservation of the infringing content or a trusted timestamp fixation; information identifying the infringer (after filing, you may apply to the court to obtain it from the platform); and evidence of the harm, such as medical records, workplace discipline and materials showing lowered social standing. Serious insults and defamation may also constitute a criminal offence, and the private prosecution path can be assessed in parallel.

I hit someone — beyond medical expenses, do I also have to pay for emotional distress?

It depends on the consequences. Where infringement of a natural person's personal rights causes serious mental harm, the infringed has the right to claim compensation for mental distress (Article 1183 of the Civil Code of the PRC). In traffic accidents, it is usually upheld where disability or death results, and generally not upheld where the injury is minor without serious lasting consequences. The amount is set at the court's discretion, taking into account the degree of fault, the harm and local living standards, and can be paid within the death and disability limit of the compulsory insurance.

Disputes That Recur in Personal Injury Compensation

  1. The insurer denies the claim on policy clauses. How the problem appears: the client cannot make sense of a policy dozens of pages long and does not know how to argue back. How it is handled: review clause by clause whether the duty to flag and explain each exemption was performed — without performance the clause does not take effect; common denial grounds such as changed vehicle use and driver qualifications each have corresponding review points.
  2. The appraisal timing was missed. How the problem appears: done too early, the appraisal is overturned when the condition changes; done too late, the limitation period tightens. How it is handled: anchor on the point where treatment concludes and the condition stabilizes, and work backwards from the limitation period; where the other side objects to the appraisal opinion, respond within the evidence period and apply for a new appraisal when necessary.
  3. The compensation items cannot be figured out. How the problem appears: the party at fault advances part of the expenses and then disappears; the victim cannot calculate the standards, afraid of asking too little or too much. How it is handled: list the statutory items one by one — lost wages, nursing and dependents' living expenses each have their calculation standards and proof requirements; negotiate on the basis of a complete schedule to avoid omissions.
  4. A pre-existing condition is used to press the price down. How the problem appears: the victim has an old illness, the insurer presses the price down with injury contribution, and the family lacks confidence. How it is handled: make clear that personal constitution is not a statutory ground for reducing liability and hold to the adjudication rule of full compensation; at the same time, separate the records of the old condition from the new injury to prevent conflation.
  5. The infringing content can be deleted at any time. How the problem appears: a photo is stolen or a rumor spread, and the content may be deleted at any moment — by the time suit is considered, the evidence is gone. How it is handled: upon discovering the infringement, notarize it or fix it with a trusted timestamp at once, then send a lawyer's letter demanding deletion and an apology; the evidence of dissemination scope and duration directly determines the compensation amount.

What to Prepare Before Claiming Compensation

  1. Accident and liability materials: the traffic accident determination, police report records, scene photos and videos, and dashcam data.
  2. Injury and treatment materials: outpatient and emergency records, the inpatient file, diagnosis certificates, medical invoices and itemized bills, and prescriptions for externally purchased medicine.
  3. Income and lost-work materials: the employment contract, salary statements, tax records and lost-work certificates; for the self-employed, the business license and operating statements.
  4. Appraisal and insurance materials: the disability appraisal opinion and appraisal fee invoice, the policies of the party at fault and of yourself, and claim communication records.
  5. Online infringement materials: notarization or timestamp fixation of the infringing content, information on the infringing account, screenshots of dissemination data, and receipts for enforcement expenses.

Our Personal Injury Lawyers

Cases & Articles in This Practice Area