CASES · LAW THROUGH CASES

Guangzhou Cross-Border Lawyers: Jurisdiction, Service of Process and Recognition of Judgments in Cross-Border Contracts

We advise on matters governed by the laws of the People's Republic of China. The trouble with cross-border deals usually surfaces only when something goes wrong: when the contract was signed, everyone watched price and delivery dates, and no one wrote down where disputes would be heard or which country's law would apply; the counterparty is abroad, the summons cannot be served, and the case cannot even be docketed; the lawsuit is finally won, but the other side's assets are overseas and the judgment is not recognized there. The biggest difference between foreign-related civil and commercial disputes and domestic cases is an extra procedural threshold at every step — jurisdiction, service of process, evidence gathering, choice of law, and cross-border recognition and enforcement of judgments — and any of them can jam. To handle such disputes, first read the dispute resolution clause of the contract carefully, then map out where the other side's assets are — pick the wrong jurisdiction clause, and every later step is fought in someone else's procedure.

Common Scenarios of Foreign-Related Civil and Commercial Disputes and Jurisdiction

  1. The common scenarios cluster around: cross-border sale of goods and foreign trade receivables, cross-border e-commerce and platform disputes, foreign-related services and engineering cooperation, cross-border investment, and foreign-related marriage and succession. On receiving a case, first check whether the contract contains a jurisdiction clause and a choice-of-law clause — these two clauses determine every path that follows.
  2. The other side having no domicile outside the mainland does not make filing impossible: where the place of contract signing, the place of performance, the location of the subject matter, the location of attachable property, the place of the tortious act, or the domicile of a representative office is within the mainland, mainland courts have a jurisdictional connecting point; the 2023 amendment to the Civil Procedure Law further added a catch-all for other appropriate connections with China — the jurisdictional threshold is broader than before.
  3. The parties may choose the competent court by written agreement; choosing a foreign court means the judgment must later come back to the mainland for recognition and enforcement — an extra procedure. Think it through when signing the jurisdiction clause: the lawsuit should be designed to land where the other side's assets are.
  4. Foreign-related civil and commercial cases are accepted by the courts with jurisdiction, and major foreign-related cases fall under the intermediate people's courts; some cities centralize foreign-related commercial cases in designated courts — confirm the accepting court before filing.
  5. Real property disputes are governed by the law of the place where the property is located (Article 36 of the Law of the PRC on the Application of Law to Foreign-Related Civil Relations); where the property is in the mainland, an agreement on foreign jurisdiction cannot bypass the mainland courts.
  6. A foreign-invested enterprise is a Chinese legal person registered in the mainland, and its disputes with domestic parties are usually not foreign-related cases; whether a case is foreign-related depends on whether the parties' domiciles, the location of the subject matter or the place where the legal facts occurred involve a cross-border element.

Key Points on Choice of Law and Recognition and Enforcement of Judgments and Awards

  1. The parties to a foreign-related civil relation may expressly choose the applicable law in accordance with the law (Article 3 of the Law of the PRC on the Application of Law to Foreign-Related Civil Relations); but choice is possible only where the law expressly permits it — not every relation can be freely assigned a law.
  2. The parties to a contract dispute may agree on the applicable law; absent a choice, the law of the habitual residence of the party whose performance best characterizes the contract applies, or another law most closely connected with the contract (Article 41).
  3. Tort liability is governed by the law of the place of the tortious act; where the parties share a common habitual residence, the law of that residence applies; after the tortious act occurs, the parties may also agree on the applicable law (Article 44).
  4. Foreign-related family matters have special rules: divorce by litigation is governed by the law of the forum (Article 27); statutory succession is governed by the law of the decedent's habitual residence at death, and statutory succession to real property by the law of the place where the property is located (Article 31).
  5. For a foreign court judgment to be enforced in the mainland, an application for recognition and enforcement must be made to the competent intermediate people's court, which reviews it under the international treaties China has concluded or acceded to, or under the principle of reciprocity; a judgment without a treaty or reciprocity basis usually requires re-litigating the same dispute in the mainland.
  6. Recognition and enforcement of foreign arbitral awards goes through the Convention on the Recognition and Enforcement of Foreign Arbitral Awards (the New York Convention), of which China has been a member since 1987; the courts review only the procedural grounds listed in the Convention and do not re-examine the merits — when signing a cross-border contract, choosing arbitration in the dispute resolution clause usually serves later enforcement better than choosing a foreign court.

Common Questions on Cross-Border Disputes

The contract chooses Hong Kong law. Will a mainland court accept it?

Yes. Contract disputes allow the parties to agree on the applicable law. In trial the mainland court must ascertain the content of Hong Kong law, and both sides may assist with legal opinions and expert testimony; where the law still cannot be ascertained by reasonable means, mainland law applies. Choosing a foreign law is not a matter of one sentence — the cost and time of ascertainment must be built into litigation expectations.

The other side is abroad and the summons cannot be served. What can I do?

Foreign-related service has channels including service under international treaties, diplomatic channels, postal service and electronic service, and where the other side has an agent or branch in the mainland, service can be made on it; the 2023 amendment to the Civil Procedure Law further broadened the channels. Where service truly proves impossible, service by public announcement is the last resort, but the announcement period is long — mapping the other side's exact address and mainland contact points before filing can save months.

How is a foreign arbitral award enforced in the mainland?

Apply for recognition and enforcement to the intermediate people's court of the respondent's domicile or the place where its property is located; the court reviews under the New York Convention and looks only at procedural grounds such as invalidity of the arbitration agreement, lack of proper notice or exceeding the scope of arbitration, without re-examining the merits. Prepare the original award, the original arbitration agreement and certified translations — none of the procedural materials can be missing.

I won a lawsuit abroad. Can the judgment be enforced directly in the mainland?

Not automatically. An application for recognition and enforcement must be made to a mainland court, which reviews it under international treaties or reciprocity; where there is neither a treaty nor a reciprocity basis between China and the country that rendered the judgment, the application will be dismissed, and the same dispute can only be re-litigated in the mainland. Assess whether the judgment is worth obtaining before suing abroad.

When contracting with a foreign company, is it good to agree on the jurisdiction of a foreign court?

In most cases, no. Where the other side's main assets are in the mainland, agreeing on a foreign court means the judgment must later come back to the mainland for recognition and enforcement — an extra threshold for nothing. The more practical choices are mainland court jurisdiction or an arbitration clause — arbitral awards travel across borders through the New York Convention, which covers far more countries and regions than judgment recognition arrangements.

My cross-border e-commerce business has been sued by an overseas buyer. Do I have to go abroad to respond?

First check whether the two sides have an agreed jurisdiction clause, then whether the accepting court has jurisdiction under its local law. Do not ignore foreign litigation documents: once a default judgment is rendered, the other side may bring it to the mainland for recognition and enforcement, and by the time the court reviews the treaty and reciprocity basis, your chance to raise procedural defenses will have passed. Engage a lawyer early to assess whether to respond or settle.

Will mainland courts accept evidence formed overseas in foreign-related marriage and succession matters?

Yes, but formalities must be completed. Evidence formed overseas must be notarized by the notarial authorities of the country where it was formed and authenticated by the Chinese embassy or consulate there, or undergo the certification formalities in the treaties between China and that country; evidence involving identity relationships is subject to stricter requirements. Have translations produced by qualified agencies — procedural defects kill evidence more easily than substantive ones.

Are there still two separate sets of rules for domestic and foreign investment?

Foreign investment is governed by a system of pre-establishment national treatment plus a negative list: outside the negative list, domestic and foreign investment are administered on the same footing; within the negative list, entry is subject to the prescribed conditions (Article 4 of the Foreign Investment Law of the PRC). Before launching an investment, check the intended industry against the negative list.

Recurring Procedural Difficulties in Foreign-Related Cases

  1. The contract said nothing about jurisdiction or choice of law. How the problem appears: at signing only price and delivery were discussed; when a dispute arises, it turns out that where to sue and under which law were never agreed. How it is handled: in cross-border contracts, treat the dispute resolution clause as a core clause — jurisdiction, applicable law and the language version are written clearly in one pass, and templates provided by the other side are not signed without review.
  2. Service of process stalls and drags down the schedule. How the problem appears: the defendant is overseas, the summons cannot be served, and docketing and trial are delayed again and again. How it is handled: before filing, map the other side's exact domicile and mainland contact points, and fix in advance the channels available such as electronic and postal service; leave ample room for service in the time budget.
  3. Winning the case without collecting the money. How the problem appears: the lawsuit is won, but the other side's main assets are overseas and the mainland judgment cannot travel. How it is handled: assess the distribution of the other side's assets before filing; prefer arbitration in the dispute resolution clause — arbitral awards travel across borders through the New York Convention and go further than court judgments.
  4. Overseas evidence comes back unusable. How the problem appears: contracts and documents formed overseas are submitted directly and excluded for lack of certification formalities. How it is handled: handle overseas evidence through notarization and authentication or treaty certification procedures, with stricter treatment for identity relationships; leave translations to qualified agencies — procedural compliance comes before substantive preparation.
  5. Budgeting by the rhythm of a domestic case. How the problem appears: the litigation budget is planned at three to five months, but service, ascertainment of foreign law, and recognition and enforcement each overrun. How it is handled: budget foreign-related cases on a scale of years, with separate timelines for service, ascertainment and enforcement, and communicate with the court in advance at key milestones.

What to Bring to a Consultation on a Foreign-Related Matter

  1. Contract texts: the original contract containing the jurisdiction, choice-of-law and arbitration clauses and all supplementary agreements, together with any foreign-language versions
  2. Performance records: orders, bills of lading, customs declarations, payment slips, invoices, and correspondence by email and chat
  3. Party materials: registration documents of the domestic and foreign entities, proof of identity of representatives, and powers of attorney (those issued overseas require certification formalities)
  4. Existing legal instruments: originals of foreign judgments and arbitral awards and certified translations
  5. Dispute evidence: proof of the breach and of the loss calculation; evidence formed overseas is first prepared to meet notarization-authentication or treaty requirements
  6. Asset leads: information on the other side's mainland bank accounts, real property, equity and due receivables

Our Cross-Border Matters Lawyers

Cases & Articles in This Practice Area