CASES · LAW THROUGH CASES

Guangzhou Medical Dispute Lawyers: Liability Determination for Medical Malpractice and Compensation Claims

We advise on matters governed by the laws of the People's Republic of China. When a loved one is harmed during treatment, it is the most wrenching scenario in a medical dispute: a surgery goes wrong, a condition is left too long, medication causes a problem — and the family, often before even understanding what happened, is met with the answer that "treatment itself carries risks". The most common predicaments: the medical records are in the hospital's hands, and the family does not know whether they can be copied or how to ask; they want to know whether the hospital was at fault but cannot read the treatment records; they hear an appraisal is needed and worry the appraisal agency is connected to the hospital; when they consider suing, they are unsure even of when the limitation period starts to run. Seal and copy the medical records immediately after the incident; leave fault and causation to the appraisal — do not jump to conclusions yourself; and list the compensation items one by one under the statutory rules — no one will fill in what you leave out.

Common Scenarios of Medical Disputes and the Paths to Protect Your Rights

  1. Medical disputes most often arise in these areas: surgical procedures and the handling of complications, delayed diagnosis or missed and mistaken diagnoses, medication and infusion or transfusion reactions, obstetric and neonatal care, and medical aesthetics. When an adverse outcome occurs, do not rush to argue about responsibility — the first step is always to secure the medical records.
  2. Patients have the right to inspect and copy their medical records, and the medical institution shall provide them in a timely manner (Article 1225 of the Civil Code of the PRC); after a dispute arises, the patient may request that both sides jointly seal the medical records, and the sealed records may be photocopies.
  3. Paths to resolution: negotiate with the hospital, apply for third-party mediation by a people's mediation committee for medical disputes, or file a civil lawsuit. Where the harm is serious and liability is sharply contested, involve a lawyer early — do not let negotiation drag into a war of attrition.
  4. Not every adverse outcome is the hospital's responsibility: a medical institution bears compensation liability only where the patient is harmed in the course of diagnosis and treatment and the medical institution or its staff were at fault (Article 1218 of the Civil Code of the PRC).
  5. The limitation period is three years, running from the date the right-holder knew or should have known of the harm and the obligor (Article 188 of the Civil Code of the PRC); do not let the period lapse in a long wait for negotiation.
  6. Where negotiation and mediation fail, litigation usually enters the medical malpractice appraisal procedure: the appraisal examines whether the diagnosis and treatment involved fault, whether there is causation between the fault and the harm, and the degree of contribution; the appraisal opinion is the core basis for apportioning liability.

Key Points in Determining Medical Malpractice Liability

  1. Liability turns on three elements: fault in the diagnosis and treatment, harm to the patient, and causation between the fault and the harm — all three are indispensable, and proving them depends heavily on the medical records and the appraisal opinion.
  2. Where a medical institution conceals or refuses to provide medical records related to the dispute, or loses, forges, tampers with or unlawfully destroys medical records, fault on the part of the medical institution is presumed (Article 1222 of the Civil Code of the PRC).
  3. Where medical staff fail to perform the duty of disclosure and carry out surgery, special examinations or special treatment without the explicit consent of the patient or a close relative, the medical institution shall bear compensation liability (Article 1219 of the Civil Code of the PRC).
  4. Where a patient is harmed by defective drugs or disinfection products or defective medical devices, or by the transfusion of substandard blood, the patient may claim compensation from the manufacturer or blood supplier, or from the medical institution (Article 1223 of the Civil Code of the PRC).
  5. A medical institution bears no compensation liability where the patient or a close relative fails to cooperate with standard diagnosis and treatment, or where diagnosis and treatment was difficult given the medical level of the time (Article 1224(1) of the Civil Code of the PRC); whether a complication can be excused turns on whether the hospital performed its corresponding duty of care.
  6. The burden of proof is allocated roughly as follows: the patient proves the fact of treatment and the harm, and preliminarily points out the questionable aspects of the treatment; a hospital that claims no fault and no causation must submit the complete medical records and other evidence to prove it; once in the appraisal procedure, cross-examination revolves around the appraisal opinion.

Questions Patients Care About

Does signing the consent form before surgery mean the case cannot be won?

No. Signing the informed consent form only means "I have been told of the risks" — it does not exempt the hospital from liability. What the hospital must perform is the duty of disclosure: the condition, the medical measures, the risks and the alternatives must all be explained clearly; where the surgery itself was performed with fault and improper handling caused harm, compensation liability still applies (Articles 1219 and 1218 of the Civil Code of the PRC). A signature only shows that the disclosure procedure was gone through; treatment fault is investigated all the same.

The medical records are in the hospital's hands and I cannot get copies. What can I do?

You have a statutory right to copies. Bring the patient's ID card (family members acting on the patient's behalf should also bring proof of kinship), go directly to the hospital's medical records room with a written application, and demand copies and sealing of the complete records, including the subjective records such as progress notes and consultation opinions. Where the hospital delays or refuses to provide them, or the records show traces of loss or tampering, the law directly presumes the hospital is at fault (Articles 1222 and 1225 of the Civil Code of the PRC).

The appraisal agency was found by the hospital — can its conclusion be trusted?

In litigation the appraisal is not arranged by the hospital: it is commissioned by the court, the two sides may agree on the appraisal agency, and failing agreement the court designates one — the hospital does not have the final say. If you disagree with the appraisal opinion, you may apply for the appraiser to appear in court for questioning, and in statutory circumstances you may apply for a new appraisal. Organizing the disputed points into a written submission to the appraisal agency before the appraisal works far better than complaining afterwards.

The patient has passed away. Can an appraisal still be done?

Yes. Where the patient has died, a cause-of-death appraisal can be performed, and a medical malpractice appraisal on the treatment fault is also possible, based mainly on written materials such as the medical records, imaging and test reports; where an autopsy is needed to determine the cause of death, it must be requested within the prescribed time limit (generally within forty-eight hours of death, extendable where freezing facilities are available). When the family is unsure, first raise the autopsy question with the medical institution in writing and keep a record.

The hospital says this was a complication, unavoidable — does that exempt it from liability?

Not necessarily. Whether a complication can be excused depends on whether the hospital performed the duty of care corresponding to the medical level of the time: whether the pre-operative assessment was adequate, whether the intra-operative procedure met standards, and whether post-operative observation and handling were timely — if any link failed, the complication is not automatically excused. Only in statutory circumstances such as the patient or close relatives failing to cooperate with standard treatment does the hospital bear no liability (Article 1224(1) of the Civil Code of the PRC).

Is the agreement signed in a private settlement with the hospital valid?

Yes — think it through before signing. Once a one-off settlement agreement is signed, it is very hard to claim more when the disability later worsens or follow-up treatment costs exceed expectations. Do not sign a final settlement while the harm has not yet stabilized (the disability grade has not been assessed and follow-up treatment has not ended); where the agreed amount is obviously below the statutory compensation, you may request rescission for manifest unfairness within the statutory period, but the burden of proof is not light.

What compensation can be claimed in a medical dispute lawsuit?

Calculated under the personal injury compensation rules: medical expenses, lost wages, nursing fees, transportation costs, hospitalization meal subsidies and nutrition expenses; where disability results, also disability compensation and assistive device costs; where death results, death compensation, funeral expenses and dependents' living expenses; plus moral damages (Article 1179 of the Civil Code of the PRC). The specific amount is shared according to the proportion of liability — the hospital pays in proportion to the causal contribution of its fault.

If a medical aesthetics procedure goes wrong, does it count as a medical dispute?

Yes. Medical aesthetics is a diagnosis and treatment activity governed by the same medical malpractice liability rules: examine the qualifications of the institution and the practitioners, and examine fault and causation. Where a beauty salon performs medical aesthetics items such as injections and laser treatment beyond its licensed scope, unlicensed medical practice may also be involved — a complaint can be filed with the health authority at the same time, and the administrative sanction result in turn serves as evidence for the civil claim.

Recurring Difficulties in Handling Medical Disputes

  1. The medical records were not sealed in time. How the problem appears: the family spends the time arguing in the ward, and by the time sealing is requested, the key records have been supplemented or altered. How it is handled: demand in writing at the earliest moment that all medical records be sealed and copied, and photograph the sealing process — this is the foundation of every subsequent claim.
  2. Treating a medical dispute like an ordinary tort case. How the problem appears: assuming that a bad outcome means the hospital should pay, without understanding that fault and causation must be established through appraisal. How it is handled: first have a professional assess the points of fault in the medical records, then decide between negotiation and litigation — do not waste time on the wrong expectations.
  3. Failing at the appraisal stage. How the problem appears: the appraisal materials were not cross-examined and the disputed points were not clearly stated; only when the appraisal opinion comes out unfavorable does the family panic. How it is handled: before the appraisal, organize the treatment timeline and objections into a written submission; confirm the submitted materials item by item, check the appraisal opinion clause by clause, and make objections specific to a particular act of diagnosis or treatment.
  4. Being worn down by "going through the process". How the problem appears: the hospital asks the patient to wait for insurance, for internal discussions, dragging on for months while evidence and the limitation period slip away. How it is handled: set a deadline for negotiation and sue as soon as it passes; once in judicial proceedings, obtaining the medical records and commissioning the appraisal carry compulsory force.
  5. Signing the settlement too early. How the problem appears: a sum of compensation is accepted and a "one-off settlement" is signed, while the subsequent harm far exceeds expectations. How it is handled: do not sign a final settlement before the disability grade and follow-up treatment costs are determined; if you must sign, write in a reservation of the right to claim subsequent treatment expenses.

What to Prepare Before Negotiating with the Hospital

  1. Complete medical records: outpatient records, admission notes, surgical and anesthesia records, test reports, imaging films and reports (sealed copies and photocopies)
  2. Identity and kinship proof: the patient's ID card; where a family member handles the matter, also bring the household register, marriage certificate or other proof of kinship
  3. Expense receipts: medical invoices, transportation and accommodation receipts, and nursing fee payment vouchers, organized in chronological order
  4. Income and lost-wage proof: the employment contract, salary statements and tax records, used to calculate lost wages
  5. Communication records: audio and video recordings of dealings with the hospital, written replies, mediation records, and the handover receipt for the sealed medical records
  6. Follow-up treatment records: diagnosis certificates and medical records after transfer to another hospital, used to prove the continuation of the harm and subsequent treatment costs

Our Medical Dispute Lawyers

Cases & Articles in This Practice Area