CASES · LAW THROUGH CASES

Guangzhou Equity Lawyers: Equity Transfer, Valuation Adjustment Buyback and Corporate Governance Disputes

We advise on matters governed by the laws of the People's Republic of China. Putting money in is easy; getting money out is hard — this is the most common situation in investment and M&A disputes. The transfer price has been paid, but the corporate registration change is endlessly delayed; the valuation adjustment has matured with performance targets missed, and the buyback money is dragged out unpaid; a minority shareholder is diluted by a round of capital increase and cannot even see the company books; only after closing are hidden guarantees and pending lawsuits discovered, and the former shareholder has already disappeared. The more carelessly the transaction documents are signed, the more passive the position in later enforcement. The boundary of validity of every clause in the transaction documents should be clarified first; the procedural evidence of contributions, resolutions and disclosures should be fixed from the very beginning; and the exit path should be designed before negotiations break down — once it truly comes to court, everything rests on what was left behind at signing.

Common Scenarios and Deal Structures in Investment and M&A

  1. Equity transfer and capital increase are the two basic paths: the money for taking over existing shares goes to the transferor, while the money subscribed for newly increased registered capital goes to the company. The tax burden, the destination of the funds and the dilution effect are entirely different, and the consequences of choosing the wrong path are borne by oneself.
  2. The subscribed capital system does not mean no contribution is required: the subscribed capital contribution shall be paid in full within five years from the date of establishment of the company (Article 47 of the Company Law of the PRC). The larger the subscribed amount written, the greater the liability of the unpaid part in debt repayment and equity transfer scenarios.
  3. Be especially careful when taking over equity for which the contribution has not been paid up: where equity whose contribution period has not yet expired is transferred, the contribution obligation passes to the transferee together with the equity, and if the transferee fails to pay in full and on time, the transferor bears supplementary liability (Article 88 of the Company Law of the PRC) — in due diligence, first find out the gap between the subscribed and the paid-up amounts.
  4. Where a shareholder transfers equity to an outsider, the quantity, price, method of payment and time limit of the transfer shall be notified to the other shareholders in writing, and the other shareholders have a right of first refusal on the same terms, which is deemed waived if no reply is given within thirty days (Article 84 of the Company Law of the PRC). If the procedure is not followed correctly, the validity of the transfer will be challenged.
  5. The valuation adjustment clause must be written clearly: the trigger conditions for buyback, the method of calculating the buyback price, and the time limit for payment. Where the valuation adjustment is made directly with the target company, performance is subject to the mandatory rules on company buyback and profit distribution — signing it does not mean the money can be obtained (the adjudication rule established in the Minutes of the National Courts' Civil and Commercial Trial Work Conference; the Minutes are not a judicial interpretation, so no article number is cited).
  6. The basic process of an M&A transaction is letter of intent, due diligence, transaction documents, and closing with corporate registration change. Where a concentration of undertakings reaches the declaration standard set by the State Council, it shall be declared in advance and may not be implemented without declaration; failure to declare may lead to an order to stop implementing the concentration and a fine.

Key Points in Deal Risk and Liability Determination

  1. The validity of a corporate resolution has three categories of defect: a resolution whose content violates laws or administrative regulations is void (Article 25 of the Company Law of the PRC); where the convening procedure or voting method violates the law, regulations or the articles of association, or the content of the resolution violates the articles of association, a shareholder may request its revocation within sixty days from the date the resolution was made (Article 26); where no meeting was held and no vote was taken, the resolution is not established.
  2. Determination and liability for capital withdrawal: after the company is established, a shareholder may not withdraw capital; what is withdrawn shall be returned, and where losses are caused to the company, the responsible directors, supervisors and senior managers bear joint and several compensation liability together with that shareholder (Article 53 of the Company Law of the PRC). Fabricating debts to transfer out the contribution and preparing false statements to distribute profits are typical forms.
  3. A minority shareholder's inspection of the books is a statutory right: shareholders have the right to inspect and copy the articles of association, the register of shareholders, resolutions of the shareholders' meeting and the board of directors, and financial accounting reports, and may also request to inspect the accounting books and accounting vouchers (Article 57 of the Company Law of the PRC). Where the company refuses without justifiable reason, an action can be brought to assert the inspection right.
  4. The risk of commingled assets in a one-person company: where the shareholder of a company with only one shareholder cannot prove that the company's assets are independent of the shareholder's own assets, the shareholder bears joint and several liability for the company's debts (Article 23(3) of the Company Law of the PRC). Before acquiring the equity of a one-person company, first check the financial independence clearly.
  5. Whether a valuation adjustment can actually be performed depends on two gates: where the investor requests the target company to buy back the equity, the court examines whether this violates the mandatory rules that shareholders may not withdraw capital and on share buyback; where monetary compensation is requested, the court examines whether the target company has distributable profits — a request that cannot pass the gate will not be supported, or only partially supported.
  6. Hidden debts and contingent liabilities must be excluded before pricing: external guarantees, pending litigation, tax arrears and unpaid social insurance are investigated item by item; the transaction documents use representations, warranties and indemnity clauses as a backstop, and discoveries after closing are recovered as agreed.

Questions Shareholders and Investors Care About

The equity transfer agreement is signed, but the other side keeps refusing to cooperate with the corporate registration change. What can I do?

Corporate registration change is not a condition for the contract to take effect, but without the change the transfer cannot be asserted against third parties, and the other side can still pledge or resell the same equity. The agreement should write the cooperation with the change as an explicit obligation and bind it to the payment milestones. Where you have performed the payment obligation and the other side still delays, you can sue for continued performance, and after the court judgment, apply for compulsory change based on the effective instrument.

The valuation adjustment has matured and the performance target was missed. Can I directly demand a buyback?

It depends on who the counterparty is. Where the valuation adjustment is made with the founders or original shareholders, claiming the buyback money under the agreement is generally supported by the courts. Where it is made directly with the target company, the court examines whether the buyback violates the capital maintenance rules of the company; if the target company has not completed a capital reduction or has no distributable profits, the buyback request can hardly be enforced directly. Who is chosen as the buyback obligor at signing determines whether the valuation adjustment can be cashed out.

A capital increase diluted my equity. Can I stop it if I don't agree?

A capital increase resolution is valid once passed by shareholders representing two-thirds or more of the voting rights; your opposition alone cannot stop it. What can be done: check the convening and voting procedure of the resolution for defects, and request revocation if the procedure was unlawful; check whether the increase price is obviously low and whether benefits are being channeled to specific related parties; use the inspection right first, get the books and vouchers in hand, and then assess further action.

The contribution period for my subscribed capital has not yet expired. Will I be pursued if the company owes debts?

Possibly. Where the company cannot pay its due debts, the company or a creditor whose claim is due has the right to demand that a shareholder who has subscribed capital but whose contribution period has not yet expired make the contribution ahead of schedule — the amount you subscribed is the extent of your liability to the outside. Write the subscribed amount within your means; bigger is not more face-saving.

There is a problem with a nominee shareholding. Can the actual contributor get the equity back?

The nominee agreement is in principle valid between the two parties, and where the actual contribution can be proved, the investment rights and interests can be claimed against the nominal shareholder. But to change from concealed to registered shareholder requires the consent of more than half of the other shareholders of the company. Where the nominal shareholder sells the equity to a bona fide third party without authorization, the equity cannot be recovered, and only damages can be claimed against the nominal shareholder. Write the exit and breach liability clauses from the very beginning of the nominee arrangement.

What exactly should M&A due diligence examine?

Four lines: the entity line checks the internal corporate registry file, the equity structure, and pledges and freezes; the financial line checks audit reports, bank statements, tax filings and paid-up vouchers; the liability line checks external guarantees, pending litigation, arbitration and administrative penalties; the asset line checks the ownership and encumbrances of real estate and intellectual property. All materials provided by the other side must be verified against the original vouchers; where the disclosure is incomplete, use representations, warranties and indemnity clauses to lock in liability.

The investment money was paid directly to the major shareholder personally. Is this an investment or a loan?

It depends on the contract terms and the flow of funds. Capital increase money should go into the company account; money paid to an individual neither completes the contribution obligation nor secures the equity — when the company does not acknowledge it, you can only pursue the individual who received the money. The remedy afterwards is to sign a supplementary agreement, pass a make-up resolution, map the payment path to the registered capital or the transfer price, and then complete the registration change.

The shareholders have fallen out. Can I demand that the company buy back my equity?

Statutory buyback is limited to specific circumstances: the company has been profitable for five consecutive years and meets the distribution conditions but does not distribute dividends; the company merges, splits or transfers major assets; a dissolution ground provided in the articles of association arises but a resolution is passed to continue the company — in these cases a shareholder who voted against may request the company to acquire the equity at a reasonable price. Where none of these applies, exit goes through equity transfer, targeted capital reduction or dissolution and liquidation; there is no channel of "leaving whenever you want".

Disputes That Recur in Investment Transactions

  1. Signing the agreement without completing the change. How the problem appears: most of the transfer price has been paid, the corporate registration is delayed, and the other side pledges the same equity again. How it is handled: bind the registration change to the payment milestones in the agreement and retain a sufficient final installment; where the other side delays, sue promptly for continued performance and apply for conduct preservation.
  2. The valuation adjustment stayed oral. How the problem appears: "if we fail to go public, the money will be refunded" was said over WeChat, but it was not written into the body of the agreement, and the other side denies it afterwards. How it is handled: the buyback trigger conditions, price and time limit must enter the body of the agreement; negotiation minutes and chat records can only serve as auxiliary evidence and cannot replace the clause.
  3. Due diligence as a formality. How the problem appears: only the summary statements provided by the other side are reviewed, and guarantees, lawsuits and tax arrears surface after closing. How it is handled: due diligence must go down to the voucher level — bank statements, tax records, litigation information and social insurance payments are checked item by item; have the original shareholders make representations and warranties on the completeness of the disclosure, with compensation as agreed upon breach.
  4. Treating the investment as a loan repayable on demand. How the problem appears: when the company performs poorly, the investor demands to withdraw the shares and get the money back, unable to tell equity from debt. How it is handled: after contributing capital and becoming a shareholder, one is a shareholder, not a creditor; exit goes through transfer, capital reduction or liquidation. Those who want a fixed return should have structured the deal as a secured loan from the beginning.
  5. The minority shareholder only thinks of inspecting the books when no money is distributed. How the problem appears: after years of shareholding without ever reading the statements, when profit transfer is suspected, even the books cannot be obtained. How it is handled: the inspection right is a statutory right; apply in writing to inspect the books and keep a record, and sue if refused. Making inspection a regular routine costs far less than remedying afterwards.

Transaction Documents to Prepare Before the Consultation

  1. Transaction documents: the equity transfer or capital increase agreement, supplementary agreements, the letter of intent, and the text containing the valuation adjustment clause
  2. Corporate registry files: the articles of association and all amendments, the register of shareholders, and the internal registration files of the establishment and all changes
  3. Contribution vouchers: bank statements, the capital verification report, the capital contribution certificate, and paid-up records
  4. Corporate resolutions: resolutions of the shareholders' meeting and the board of directors, meeting notices, sign-in sheets and voting records
  5. Financial materials: audit reports, financial statements, and tax filing records (where pricing and performance are disputed)
  6. Communications records: WeChat and email exchanges, negotiation minutes, demand letters and proof of service

Our Investment Dispute Lawyers

Cases & Articles in This Practice Area