CASES · LAW THROUGH CASES

Guangzhou Administrative Litigation Lawyers: Handling Administrative Penalties, Administrative Omission and 'Suing the Government' Cases

We advise on matters governed by the laws of the People's Republic of China. In cases of citizens suing the government, what clients fear most is the imbalance of power: one administrative decision arrives — a fine, an order to suspend business, a demolition deadline — and the survival of a business is at stake; an application to the registration authority to correct an error is turned away at the window with a one-page refusal; a complaint sinks without a trace and the statutory reply deadline passes with no response. The most common predicaments: panic upon receiving a penalty decision, missing the sixty-day window for administrative reconsideration (the procedure for asking a superior agency to review the act), or not knowing whether to seek reconsideration first or sue directly; some give up altogether, assuming there is no winning against an administrative organ. First check whether the acting organ had the authority, whether the procedure was lawful and whether the evidence is complete — a considerable proportion of administrative acts fail precisely on procedure.

Practical Points for Dealing with Administrative Organs

  1. An administrative organ must have a statutory basis of authority for its actions: for an illegal structure on temporarily used collective land, the land authority shall order demolition within a time limit and, if the deadline passes, apply to the court for enforcement; a county-level or higher government carrying out the demolition directly applies the wrong law and acts without authority (confirmed by an effective ruling of the Supreme People's Court of the PRC).
  2. Real estate registration is handled by the registration authority of the county-level people's government where the property is located (Article 7(1) of the Interim Regulation on Real Estate Registration of the PRC); where the authority finds a possible error in a registration, it has a duty to verify it on its own initiative and start the correction procedure, rather than fobbing applicants off with refusals to accept.
  3. Procedural violations are where administrative cases are most often reversed: where a hearing that should have been held was not, a notice that should have been given was not, or statutory time limits were not observed, the administrative decision may be revoked or confirmed unlawful; in administrative litigation, reviewing procedure is often more powerful than arguing the merits.
  4. An administrative act that imposes obligations without corresponding rights, and is seriously imbalanced, may be found obviously unfair or manifestly improper; in a handled case, an administrative organ's decision of over 70 million yuan was withdrawn by the organ itself after judicial review began.
  5. Administrative organs may not abuse administrative power to treat out-of-town operators unequally or to exclude or restrict competition; singling out an individual operator for heavy sanctions in like circumstances is a review point for administrative monopoly.
  6. Remedies have deadlines: an application for administrative reconsideration should generally be filed within sixty days of learning of the administrative act, and the limitation for suing directly is six months; the period runs from the date the party knew or should have known of the act — once it lapses, the door to relief closes.

Administrative Dispute Cases We Have Handled

Weifa Case | The Government's 70-Million-Yuan 'Fine' Was Withdrawn by Itself — the Private Company Paid Nothing

A company obtained the leasehold of over one hundred mu of land through public bidding, invested heavily in upgrading it, and paid over eight million yuan in land reclamation fees and farmland occupation tax, only to receive an administrative decision of over 70 million yuan. After the legal team stepped in, it argued point by point on procedural violation, obvious unfairness and abuse of administrative power through unequal treatment, and filed an administrative lawsuit. In the course of the proceedings, the administrative organ revoked the decision on its own; the company ultimately did not pay a cent, and the catastrophe was reduced to zero.

Read Full Case

The Housing Authority Refused to Correct an Error and Declined to Accept an Application to Revoke a Real Estate Registration — the Court Ordered the Refusal Revoked

Li discovered a property registered under his late father's name and applied to the real estate registration authority to revoke the registration, submitting the death certificate and household register; the authority issued a refusal-to-accept notice on the spot. The court held that the materials submitted sufficed to show the registration might be erroneous, and the authority should have verified it and started the correction procedure instead of clinging to the finality of administrative acts; the additional grounds for refusal raised in the proceedings did not match the facts. The refusal notice was revoked and the authority was ordered to handle the application anew.

Read Full Case

SPC Case: Governments at or above the County Level Have No Power to Demolish Illegal Structures on Collective Land

A district government forcibly demolished a structure on collective land and the affected party sued. The Supreme People's Court of the PRC held on review that permanent structures built on temporarily used land shall be ordered demolished by the land administration authority within a time limit, and if the deadline passes, the penalizing authority shall apply to the people's court for enforcement; the district government's direct demolition under the Urban and Rural Planning Law applied the wrong law, lacked authority and violated statutory procedure. The court ultimately confirmed the demolition unlawful.

Read Full Case

Q&A on Administrative Reconsideration and Litigation

I have received an administrative penalty decision. What is the first step?

Do not rush to comply, and do not set the document aside. First check: what is the factual basis of the penalty, what does the notice of remedies say, and on what date was it served — the sixty-day reconsideration period and the six-month litigation period both run from the date you learned of the penalty. Have a lawyer review the authority, the procedure and the evidence one by one as soon as possible — the flaws of many penalty decisions hide in the procedure.

The administrative organ will not accept my application and gives no explanation. What can I do?

Keep proof that the application was submitted: the receipt, the mailing record and the window sign-off. A refusal-to-accept notice is itself an actionable administrative act — you may sue to have it revoked and the application handled anew; the law likewise provides remedies against administrative omission in the form of non-acceptance or non-response. In a handled case, a registration authority's refusal notice was revoked by court judgment.

The government says it will demolish my house. Can it do so just by saying so?

No. Take an illegal structure on collective land: the land authority shall order demolition within a time limit, and if the party does not comply, the penalizing authority shall apply to the people's court for enforcement; an administrative organ carrying out the demolition itself exceeds its authority. An effective ruling of the Supreme People's Court of the PRC has confirmed such forced demolitions unlawful.

Is there really a chance of winning a lawsuit against an administrative organ?

Administrative litigation reviews the legality of the administrative act, not the status of the parties. In a handled case, facing an administrative decision of over 70 million yuan, the legal team argued procedural violation, obvious unfairness and unequal treatment, and the organ revoked the decision itself in the course of the proceedings. The prospects of each case depend on the evidence and the outcome of the procedural review — the file must be assessed first.

The administrative organ is clearly biased and penalized only my business. What can I argue?

You may argue unequal treatment. Administrative organs may not abuse administrative power to treat out-of-town or individual operators unequally or to exclude or restrict competition; being singled out for heavy sanctions in like circumstances is precisely the review point for administrative monopoly. You may also argue that the penalty is obviously unfair or manifestly improper and seek its revocation or modification.

Between administrative reconsideration and administrative litigation, which comes first?

For most administrative disputes the choice is free: reconsideration is faster and more convenient, litigation more formal with deeper review. For certain matters the law requires reconsideration first. Mind the two deadlines: sixty days for a reconsideration application and generally six months for a direct lawsuit — petitioning or negotiation does not suspend either period, so do not wait the deadlines away.

Where Administrative Cases Usually Stall

  1. The reconsideration deadline lapsed. How the problem appears: upon receiving the penalty decision, the party stalls out of fear or petitions around, and by the time legal process comes to mind the deadline has passed. How it is handled: note the date the day the document arrives, and settle on a remedy plan as early as possible within the sixty-day reconsideration period or the six-month litigation period — petitioning does not suspend the clock.
  2. The party cannot say which step was unlawful. How the problem appears: the client dwells on how wronged they feel but cannot say which step the administrative organ got wrong. How it is handled: administrative cases start with procedure — check hearing, notice, service and time limits item by item; procedural loopholes are often more powerful than the merits.
  3. The evidence is in the other side's hands. How the problem appears: the evidence behind the administrative act and the internal approval materials are all held by the administrative organ, beyond the party's reach. How it is handled: after filing, apply to the court to obtain them, and demand that the defendant submit all evidence underlying the act and the normative documents relied upon.
  4. Frightened by a refusal to accept. How the problem appears: the application is turned away at the window and a refusal notice arrives; the party thinks there is no way forward. How it is handled: the refusal notice is itself actionable; registration authorities and other administrative organs have a duty to correct obvious errors themselves and can be compelled through litigation to handle the matter anew.

What to Prepare Before Applying for Reconsideration or Suing

  1. Original administrative documents: the penalty decision, the handling decision, notices and proof of service and receipt.
  2. Application records: receipts for applications submitted to the administrative organ, mailing vouchers and window sign-off records.
  3. Identity and title materials: identity card or business license, and title documents such as property certificates and land certificates.
  4. Process evidence: scene photos and videos, payment vouchers and communication records with the administrative organ.
  5. Proof of timing: vouchers establishing the exact date the administrative document was received, used to fix the starting point of the remedy period.

Our Administrative Dispute Lawyers

Cases & Articles in This Practice Area