CASES · LAW THROUGH CASES

Guangzhou Real Estate and Construction Lawyers: Handling Home Sale, Project Payment and Real Property Disputes

We advise on matters governed by the laws of the People's Republic of China. A home often involves a family's largest asset: the home is bought, but the seller refuses to cooperate with the transfer registration; the fully paid home is registered in someone else's name and that person turns around and denies everything; the developer has delayed delivery for years and instead demands default damages from the buyer; the construction work is done, but the contracting company quietly deregisters. The most common predicament: the risk of losing both money and home is imminent, yet the ownership of the home cannot be clearly established; the contract was signed more than a decade ago, and the other side tries to go back on it by simply calling the agreement void; when you decide to sue, you find the home is still under mortgage or seizure, one procedural step locked to the next. First examine the title documents, the validity of the contract and the registration status of mortgages and seizures; then decide between transfer, partition and damages.

How Real Estate and Construction Disputes Are Handled

  1. A transfer of a home on rural collective land between villagers of the same village is not void under the land administration rules on collectively owned land use rights (Article 11 of the Land Administration Law of the PRC is an administrative, not a validity-related mandatory provision): a sale agreement signed on the basis of mutual voluntariness, without violating any validity-related mandatory provision of laws or administrative regulations, shall be valid, and the seller shall cooperate in the title confirmation registration. (Rural collective land — zhaijidi — is village collective land allocated to villagers for housing; transfers outside the collective are restricted.)
  2. The validity of buying a home in another person's name depends on the situation: borrowing a name to circumvent credit policies, without offending public order and good morals or violating mandatory legal provisions, is valid; borrowing a name to circumvent home-purchase restriction policies offends public order and good morals and shall be found void under Article 153 of the Civil Code of the PRC. Think through the policy risk before signing a name-borrowing agreement, and keep the evidence of actual payment complete.
  3. Registering a home in a minor child's name does not shield it from enforcement: where the child is a minor without independent income, the home in the child's name may still be found to be family common property; where the purchase and registration dates are close to when the family debt arose and bad-faith evasion cannot be excluded, an outsider's objection to enforcement (a procedure for a third party to assert rights over the enforcement target) will hardly be supported.
  4. Where a developer's delayed delivery constitutes a fundamental breach, the buyer may rescind the purchase contract (Article 11 of the SPC Interpretation on Several Issues concerning the Application of Law in the Trial of Disputes over Commercial Housing Sale Contracts); the contractual period for exercising the right of rescission is usually one year — upon discovering the developer has suspended work or is overdue, assert it by letter as soon as possible, or the right may be lost.
  5. After the purchase contract is rescinded, the purpose of the mortgage loan contract can no longer be achieved and the parties may request its rescission as well (Article 19 of the same Interpretation): the developer shall return the down payment with interest, and the mortgage principal and interest already repaid by the buyer shall also be borne by the developer.
  6. The contracting company's deregistration does not mean the project payment is lost: a dissolved company shall organize liquidation in accordance with the law (Article 229 of the Company Law of the PRC); where deregistration is carried out without lawful liquidation so that liquidation becomes impossible, the creditor may claim that the shareholders and liquidation obligors bear liability for the company's debts (Article 20 of the SPC Provisions on Several Issues concerning the Application of the Company Law of the PRC (II)).

Real Estate and Construction Cases We Have Handled

Fifteen Years After Buying a Village Home, the Seller Regretted and Refused to Transfer the Title

Liu signed a Sale Agreement for a home on rural collective land with Fang, a fellow villager, paid in full and lived in the home ever since, yet Fang refused for years to cooperate in the title confirmation registration and even demanded a higher price. After Liu sued, the court found the sale agreement between villagers of the same village valid, held that Fang had breached the principle of good faith, and ordered Fang to cooperate in the registration within a time limit. When title confirmation for a home on rural collective land is blocked, title documents and the facts of performance are the key evidence.

Read Full Case

The Developer Delayed Delivery and Counterclaimed a Million — the Buyer Rescinded in Arbitration and Got a Refund

After buying a home, He rescinded the purchase contract by letter because the developer had suspended work for years and delayed delivery; the developer instead commenced arbitration, demanding continued performance and claiming over a million yuan in default damages for late payment. He filed a counterclaim. The tribunal found the developer in fundamental breach and its claim time-barred under the rescission period, ruled to rescind the purchase contract, ordered the developer to return the down payment with interest and bear the mortgage He had repaid, and dismissed all of the developer's claims.

Read Full Case

The Contracting Company Quietly Deregistered — Recovery of Project Payment from the Sole Shareholder Upheld

Liu undertook a demolition project for a company; after completion and acceptance, the company withheld over seventy thousand yuan of project payment, and then the company's sole shareholder and legal representative completed deregistration without notifying Liu. Liu sued the shareholder. The court found that the shareholder's failure to perform the liquidation notification duty had made liquidation impossible, and ordered the shareholder to pay the seventy thousand yuan plus interest. When a contracting company is deregistered, its shareholders and liquidation obligors are the realistic path for recovering project payment.

Read Full Case

Common Questions on Real Estate and Construction

I bought a village home from a fellow villager, and the seller now regrets it and calls the agreement void. What can I do?

A sale of a home on rural collective land between villagers of the same village violates no validity-related mandatory provision of laws or administrative regulations, so the agreement is valid. Where the seller regrets and refuses to cooperate in title confirmation, you may sue for continued performance and cooperation in the registration; the sale agreement, payment receipts and the fact of actual residence are the key evidence.

Is a name-borrowing home purchase agreement legally recognized at all?

It depends: borrowing a name to circumvent credit policies is generally valid; borrowing a name to circumvent home-purchase restriction policies offends public order and good morals and is void under Article 153 of the Civil Code of the PRC. After the agreement is found void, the actual payer may claim return of the contribution and corresponding losses, but ownership of the home stays with the registered person — a serious risk.

If the home is registered in my minor child's name, can it escape court enforcement?

No. A minor child has no independent income, and a home in the child's name may still be found to be family common property; where the purchase price is obviously inconsistent with the child's age and income level and the purchase timing is close to when the family debt arose, an objection to enforcement will hardly be supported. Trying to evade enforcement through a home in a minor child's name may instead aggravate liability.

The developer has delayed delivery for years. Can I cancel the purchase and get my money back?

Yes, but exercise the right of rescission promptly. Where delivery remains unperformed after demand, the buyer may rescind the purchase contract (Article 11 of the SPC Interpretation on Commercial Housing Sale Contract Disputes), and the period for exercising the right is usually only one year. After rescission, the mortgage loan contract may be rescinded together, and the developer can be required to return the down payment, interest and the mortgage already repaid.

The project payment is being withheld, and the contracting company has deregistered. Who do I claim against?

The shareholders. A dissolved company shall form a liquidation group within fifteen days of the dissolution event (Article 229 of the Company Law of the PRC); where deregistration without liquidation makes liquidation impossible, the creditor may claim that the shareholders and liquidation obligors bear liability (Article 20 of the SPC Provisions on the Company Law (II)). The internal corporate registry file, the liquidation report and the shareholders' undertakings are the main evidence.

How is a co-owned home registered in someone else's name partitioned?

The co-owners may negotiate the method of partition; failing agreement, where the home is difficult to partition or partition would diminish its value, the proceeds from valuation, auction or sale shall be divided (Article 304 of the Civil Code of the PRC). Where negotiation fails, you may sue to auction the home and distribute the proceeds by share; payment receipts and the share agreement are the basis for settling the dispute.

A rural home has no title certificate, only a collective land use certificate. Is litigation of any use?

Yes. The collective land use certificate, village construction approval documents and historical payment receipts can all prove the source of title; combined with the sale agreement, payment receipts and the fact of actual residence, they form a complete chain of title evidence. When title confirmation is blocked or a sale dispute arises, these documents work far better than oral agreements — keep them safe in ordinary times.

Recurring Difficulties in Real Estate and Construction Cases

  1. The seller regrets when prices rise. How the problem appears: the home was bought years ago without transfer, and seeing prices rise the seller simply goes back on the deal and claims the agreement is void. How it is handled: whether a same-village collective-land home sale or a nominee holding agreement is valid must be judged case by case — behind the validity dispute lies an interest dispute; build the chain of evidence with payment receipts, the fact of residence and utility payment records, then sue for continued performance.
  2. No written record of the name-borrowing purchase. How the problem appears: relations were good when the name was borrowed so no written agreement was signed; after things go wrong the other side denies everything, and the home is still registered in their name. How it is handled: build supplementary evidence around the actual payment — transfer records, mortgage repayment statements, renovation receipts and residence certificates can all prove the borrowing; without a written agreement the burden of proof is heavy, so the earlier the evidence is fixed, the better the position.
  3. The project stalls while the mortgage continues. How the problem appears: the developer suspends work and delays delivery; the buyer keeps paying the mortgage without getting the home, and is even counter-sued for default damages. How it is handled: send a demand letter and assert the right of rescission in time, watching the one-year rescission period; after rescission the mortgage loan contract can be rescinded together, avoiding the loss of both home and money.
  4. The contractor changes shells to evade payment. How the problem appears: the project is finished but payment never comes; the contractor changes shells or deregisters, and the project contact disappears. How it is handled: examine the corporate registration and liquidation procedure — where deregistration occurred without liquidation, pursue the shareholders and liquidation obligors; the construction contract, acceptance certificates, settlement statements and variation orders are the core evidence for claiming project payment.
  5. A co-owned home is disposed of without consent. How the problem appears: the co-owned home is registered in another person's name; after relations deteriorate, that person leases, mortgages or even sells it without consent. How it is handled: first confirm the co-ownership share with payment receipts and agreements, and sue for partition if negotiation fails; where physical partition is impossible, request auction and distribution of proceeds under Article 304 of the Civil Code of the PRC, and claim damages in a separate action for unauthorized disposal.

What to Bring Before the Consultation

  1. Title documents: the real property certificate, collective land use certificate, purchase contract, sale agreement, name-borrowing agreement, and inheritance or family property division materials.
  2. Payment records: bank statements for the purchase price and project payments, receipts, invoices, and mortgage repayment records.
  3. Performance and communication records: delivery notices, acceptance certificates, demand letters, correspondence, WeChat chat records, and call recordings.
  4. Party information: the other party's identity information, and the corporate registration and deregistration files and shareholder information of the developer or contracting company.
  5. Registration and procedural materials: the real estate registry search results, mortgage and seizure records, and any existing judgments or arbitral awards (if proceedings have begun).

Our Real Estate and Construction Lawyers

Cases & Articles in This Practice Area